When my editor sent me a message saying that camping was banned at Max Patch Bald for the next two years, I was sad but not surprised. The related press release said the restrictions were put in place to reduce impacts to natural resources and protect public health and safety. The overnight use restrictions might seem harsh, but I think they are the best thing for the area.
Max Patch is an easily accessed spot on the AT, and has become an increasingly popular overnight destination over the past few years—especially during the pandemic. With increased use came trash left behind, fire pits, and unsanitary practices. Despite visitor education efforts and barriers, the US Forest Service said they weren’t enough to remedy the misuse of the area within Pisgah National Forest.
As the corridors such as the AT near populated areas become busier, and educational efforts aren’t working, it makes sense to close them. Public lands are set aside for all people, but there has to be a limit to how we treat them. It might seem extreme to close this area to camping and overnight use, but if usage overwhelms the natural area’s ability to flourish, it seems like the only option.
It’s not ideal to lose the privileges of use, especially for the people who respect the area and treat it well. But that’s the price we pay.
I chatted about this closure with Benny Braden, better known as “Plug-it In Hikes.” Braden is vice president of Save Our Smokies, and last year he posted a photo of crowding and debris on Max Patch that brought attention to the abysmal condition of the area. He then helmed a major cleanup event in attempt to restore some semblance of order and cleanliness to the spot.
Braden thinks the closure is a good thing.
“This announcement by the Forest Service is perfect timing,” he said. “Save our Smokies already had a multi-organization cleanup scheduled for July 17th, and the impact with this cleanup will last longer than cleanups before.”
We all have our beloved spots that get “discovered.” Sometimes they become popular, and sometimes they get ruined. I’d rather lose access to a place I’d loved while knowing it is being protected than witness it permanently destroyed or altered by overuse and disrespect.
“I see this as a huge win for public lands,” said Braden. “When people come together for the betterment of our public lands and green spaces, great things are accomplished. Now Max Patch has an opportunity to heal and rehab to her once beautiful self for us all to enjoy again.”
If restricted access is what it takes to save the area, so be it. The fact that land management made the call to close the area to overnight use shows just how extreme the mistreatment of the area has been. Respectful users might be collateral damage, but from what I’ve heard, most of them are understanding.
Most of my recreation takes place on public lands. I utilize them as much as anyone I know, but I also understand my usage of these places is a privilege, not a right. We need to treat our public lands with the respect they deserve, or it won’t be long before we have nothing left at all.
Feature image via Maggie Slepian during a wintry traverse over Max Patch on the Appalachian Trail
